Deciding Between Roof Overlay vs Tear Off

Your roof is your home’s first line of defense against the elements, and maintaining its integrity is crucial to your family’s safety and comfort. Whether your roof is aging or has sustained damage, deciding between a roof overlay vs tear-off is a critical decision that can impact the longevity and value of your home. In this article we will explain why roof overlays should be avoided under most circumstances.

Why Replace Your Roof?

Replacing a worn-out or damaged roof is an investment that pays off in multiple ways. A new roof provides better protection from the weather, reducing the risk of moisture buildup that can lead to health hazards like mold, mildew, and bacteria growth. Additionally, a new roof enhances your home’s curb appeal, which is a significant selling point if you’re considering putting your house on the market.

Understanding the Basics of Roof Overlay vs Tear Off 

When your roof shows signs of wear, you generally have two options: a roof overlay or a tear-off.

1. Roof Tear Off and Installation. This approach involves removing the existing roofing material, inspecting and replacing damaged plywood, and installing new shingles. Although it’s more costly and time-consuming, it assures your new roof is in excellent condition for the long term and that your roof installation is warrantied.
2. Roof Overlay. This process involves installing new roofing shingles directly over the existing   roofing shingles. It’s a basic project that does not involve tearing off the existing shingles, inspecting the substrate, or applying all new roof material, including new underlayment. It is less labor-intensive, requires less material and is faster, making it a more affordable option in the short term.

The Case for Tear off and Installation

Complete Replacement of Roofing Materials

With a tear-off, your roofing contractor inspects the plywood and framing of your roof and can identify areas that have been compromised and are allowing water to leak into your home so the damaged areas can be repaired. During a new installation, every part of your roofing material is replaced and the workmanship and materials are warrantied. This ensures that any underlying issues, such as deteriorating decking or underlayment, are addressed and any future issues will fall under a warranty.

Improved Durability and Longevity

A tear-off allows for the inspection and repair of the roof structure, which eliminates the possibility of existing roof issues continuing to be a problem. Using all new materials extends the life of your new roof by up to 20 years compared to an overlay and improves your home’s energy efficiency and protection against extreme weather conditions.

Increased Property Value

A new roof installed through a tear-off can significantly boost your home’s resale value, making it a smart investment for homeowners planning to sell in the future. According to qualifiedremodeler.com, new roofs recover 109% of costs upon resale. In the study, new roofing was also the exterior project that most attracted buyers, followed by new vinyl windows, a new garage door, and new vinyl siding.

The Advantages of a Roof Overlay

Cost-Effective and Fast

An overlay is typically 50% less expensive than a tear-off because it requires less labor, time, and materials. If you’re looking for a quick, budget-friendly fix for the short term, an overlay might be the right choice.

Less Disruption

Because there’s no need to remove the old roofing materials, an overlay can be completed faster, minimizing the inconvenience to your daily life.

Safe and Convenient

Overlays eliminate the need for waste disposal, reducing the risk of accidents caused by falling debris or nails.

Potential Drawbacks of Each Option

While a tear-off offers a more comprehensive solution, it comes with higher costs. On the other hand, an overlay might save money upfront, but it can add weight to your roof, potentially leading to structural issues down the line. Additionally, an overlay doesn’t allow for the inspection and repair of the roof structure, which could leave underlying problems unresolved without a workmanship and material warranty guarantee.

Making the Right Choice

The decision between a roof overlay and tear-off is not one-size-fits-all. It depends on the current condition of your roof, your budget, and your long-term goals for your home. However, most roofing experts recommend tearing off your existing roof before installation because it provides increased durability and long-term value. Consulting with a licensed roofing contractor is crucial to assess your roof’s condition and help you make an informed decision.

Whether you choose a roof overlay or a tear-off, investing in your roof is investing in the safety, comfort, and value of your home. Don’t hesitate to discuss your options with a professional to ensure that you’re making the best choice for your unique needs.

Trust Skyline Roofing & Construction for Your Roof Installation Needs

At Skyline Roofing & Construction our roofing professionals always strive to add value to your home or business for the long term – that includes installing quality roofing and maintaining your roofing investment. Contact us today to schedule your free consultation for a new roof, roof repair, roof maintenance, or roof cleaning services. Skyline Roofing is located in Bellingham, WA and we presently serve Whatcom, Skagit, and Island Counties.

License #SKYLIRC801ML